🤔 Dear Lewis, how do I handle false accusations and personal attacks from my employees?
A talented director faces a storm of false accusations from team members. Discover how ancient Stoic wisdom can transform workplace conflicts into leadership triumphs.
Welcome back, dear readers, to another enlightening episode of “Dear Lewis.” Today, we’re diving into the turbulent waters of workplace conflict with a coaching client who’s facing a storm of false accusations and personal attacks from her own team members. Grab your philosophical life jackets, because we’re about to get stoic!
Meet Olivia: The Stoic-in-Training Director
One of my clients is Olivia (not her real name). She’s a director at a tech giant and has been there for seven years. Here’s the scoop on Olivia:
She’s a whiz at product development
She’s led some groundbreaking projects that have boosted user engagement
Most of her team respects her, and her peers admire her innovative thinking
But here’s the twist: Olivia’s feeling like she’s trapped in a corporate version of “Mean Girls.” She’s been hit with false accusations and personal attacks from a few disgruntled employees. These team members are spreading rumors, undermining her authority, and even accusing her of favoritism and unethical behavior.
She comes to me, looking like she’s just gone ten rounds with a particularly aggressive spreadsheet, asking what in the name of Silicon Valley she should do.
The Diagnosis
I tell Olivia that there’s nothing wrong with her abilities, but there’s something amiss with how she’s approaching this situation. She’s been trying to solve this like it’s a bug in her code - find the error, fix it, problem solved. But let me tell you, folks, managing difficult employees is about as predictable as a cat’s mood swings.
You know what I’m talking about. It looks something like this:
OLIVIA: “Let’s have a rational discussion about your concerns and find a solution.”
DISGRUNTLED EMPLOYEE: “You’re ruining the team and probably eat pineapple on pizza!”
OLIVIA’S INTERNAL MONOLOGUE: “If I just explain myself clearly enough, surely they’ll see reason and we can all go back to our standing desks in harmony.”
I tell her that this approach is:
Idealistic
Ineffective
Frankly, a bit like trying to debug human nature
It doesn’t address the underlying issues at play. And it makes her look like she can’t handle the complex dynamics of leadership. Her reactions reveal her need for a more philosophical approach to workplace conflicts.
The Solution: The STOIC Framework
Being a leader isn’t just about shipping great products; it’s about navigating the stormy seas of human nature with the calm of a seasoned captain. We start working together to change her approach, channeling the wisdom of the Stoics to help her weather this storm.
I share with Olivia a powerful quote from Marcus Aurelius:
“When you wake up in the morning, tell yourself: The people I deal with today will be meddling, ungrateful, arrogant, dishonest, jealous, and surly. They are like this because they can’t tell good from evil. But I have seen the beauty of good, and the ugliness of evil, and have recognized that the wrongdoer has a nature related to my own - not of the same blood or birth, but the same mind, and possessing a share of the divine.”
This perspective shift is like a breath of fresh air for Olivia. She realizes that by expecting and accepting these behaviors, she can approach them with more composure and wisdom.
Building on this, we develop the STOIC Framework for Handling Workplace Attacks:
S - Set Expectations…for Herself
Before facing another day of potential conflict, Olivia needs to mentally prepare herself. We practice a morning routine where she reminds herself of Marcus’ words, setting the stage for a day of stoic leadership.
T - Target the Work, Not the Person
When addressing issues or responding to accusations, we focus on specific behaviors and outcomes, not personal attributes. For example:
Instead of: “You’re always undermining me in meetings.”
We use: “In yesterday’s product review, there were several interruptions that disrupted the flow of the presentation. How can we work together to ensure smoother meetings in the future?”
This approach helps separate the work from personal identities, reducing emotional reactions.
O - Observe with Empathy
We practice recognizing the shared humanity in even the most difficult team members. Olivia learns to pause and consider:
“What might be causing this person to act this way? What fears or insecurities might they be grappling with?”
This doesn’t excuse bad behavior, but it helps Olivia maintain her composure and respond more effectively.
I - Illuminate the Path Forward
Rather than getting bogged down in accusations and defenses, we focus on constructive solutions. In every interaction, Olivia aims to:
Acknowledge the issue without dwelling on it
Propose a path forward
Emphasize shared goals and opportunities for growth
For instance: “I understand there’s frustration about the project timeline. Let’s look at our resources and priorities to find a solution that works for everyone and keeps us on track for our Q4 goals.”
C - Cultivate Resilience
Finally, we work on building Olivia’s internal resilience. Here, I introduce Seneca’s wisdom:
“We suffer more often in imagination than in reality.”
This reminder helps Olivia realize that many of her fears and anxieties about these conflicts are often worse than the reality. We develop practices to:
Reflect on her values and strengths daily
Celebrate small wins and progress
View challenges as opportunities for growth
Olivia learns to find satisfaction in her own actions and decisions, rather than seeking constant approval from her team.
The Takeaway
Handling false accusations and personal attacks from employees isn’t about winning every battle; it’s about maintaining your integrity and focus on what truly matters. By adopting the STOIC framework, you can navigate these choppy waters with the grace of a philosophical sailor.
Remember, in the grand odyssey of your career, these conflicts are mere whitecaps on the ocean. Your true measure as a leader is how you steer your ship through both calm and stormy seas.
And if all else fails, just remember: In the cosmic scale of things, we’re all just temporary custodians of our ergonomic chairs. So that accusation about playing favorites with project assignments? Probably not worth losing your inner peace over.
Keep cultivating that inner stillness, and may your stand-ups be ever productive!
Lewis C. Lin
CEO, ManageBetter
Simple, right? Well, not always
I'm here to help. Email me if you have any management or employee challenges. I've got your back, and your identity will remain anonymous.
Share the love ❤️
I enjoy sharing leadership and career insights. If this newsletter can benefit someone, please pass it along.
And if someone shared this edition with you, don't forget to hit that Subscribe button before you go.